- How bad
- This week
- Do it yourself
- Possible, if you are handy
- Usually
- EGR valve stays open because of soot
- Garage
- usually €399
What you notice
- Rough idle
- Stalling when stopping or at idle
- Hesitation when accelerating
- Diesel: black smoke
- The engine warning light is on
What usually causes it
| Cause | Likelihood |
|---|---|
| EGR valve stays open because of soot · €399 | Common |
| Faulty EGR valve or valve motor · €399 | Sometimes |
| Faulty control valve or wrongly connected vacuum hose, on a vacuum-operated valve | Sometimes |
| Faulty position sensor in the EGR valve | Sometimes |
| Fault in the engine computer (ECU) | Rare |
A code points to the area. Sometimes the garage only finds the real cause after that.
How to fix it
Start with what costs least.
- 1Check in the app whether the EGR valve is closed at idle.
- 2Does the valve work on vacuum? Check that the hoses are connected correctly.
- 3Have the EGR valve removed and the valve seat cleaned.
- 4If it still does not close properly after cleaning, have the valve replaced.
What to ask the garage
- Which other codes are stored, and can I have the printout?
- Which measurement shows that this is the cause?
- What does an original part cost, and what does a pattern part cost?
- What will it cost if you find more? Call me before you go ahead.
If you wait
According to the ANWB, you are better off not driving on with a faulty EGR valve. Further faults can follow, for example to the diesel particulate filter (DPF).
According to the ANWB, an EGR valve can reasonably be expected to last 100,000 km. Replacement costs 600 to 1,500 euros.
First drive with the fault
The computer stores the fault.
Second drive in a row
The engine warning light comes on.
After weeks of driving
Less pulling power, black smoke and higher fuel consumption are possible.
At the APK (the Dutch MOT)
With a P code stored, the APK inspector measures the exhaust gases. If the car’s registration lists a DPF, they always measure with a particle counter.
What it costs
It depends on the cause. Where do the prices come from? ›
| Part | At the garage | Part only |
|---|---|---|
| EGR valve | Garage €399 | Part €193 |
Background
How it works ›
What the EGR does
In the cylinder, oxygen and nitrogen form nitrogen oxides (NOx) above about 1,371 °C. Through the EGR valve, a little exhaust gas goes back to the intake. That gas takes the place of oxygen. This keeps combustion cooler, and less NOx forms.
The valve on the Saab 9-5 diesel works on vacuum. How far it opens is set by a solenoid valve that the engine computer controls with pulses.
When the computer sets the code
The Saab 9-5 diesel measures the return flow with the mass airflow sensor (MAF). If the computer commands the valve closed and more exhaust gas still flows back than intended, P0402 follows.
The ANWB (the Dutch motoring club) names contamination as the cause. Carbon deposits stop the valve from closing properly. That happens faster with lots of short trips in town and in traffic jams.
In numbers
- P0402 threshold (Saab 9-5 diesel)
- Too much flow while the valve is commanded closed1
- Flow measurement
- With the mass airflow sensor2
- NOx forms above
- About 1,371 °C2
- EGR valve lifespan
- About 100,000 km3
- Replacing the EGR valve (ANWB)
- €600 to €1,5003
- Engine warning light on
- On the second drive in a row with the same fault4
Questions
Can I keep driving with P0402?
Only gently to the garage. An EGR valve that stays open can make the engine stall when you stop, for example at a junction.
Why does my engine stall with P0402?
At idle the engine needs little air. If exhaust gas also comes in then, the mixture becomes too poor to keep the engine running.
Can I have the EGR valve disabled?
No, that is not allowed in the Netherlands. With a disabled or blanked-off EGR valve, the car no longer meets the emissions standards.
See also
Was this helpful?
· 6 sources · In het Nederlands
Sources
All sources checked on 19 November 2026.
- Saab WIS, 9-5 2011 diesel: DTC P0401 or P0402 (factory manual)
- Saab WIS, 9-5 2011 diesel: Exhaust Gas Recirculation (EGR) System Description (factory manual)
- ANWB, The EGR valve (in Dutch)
- Saab WIS, 9-4X 2011: Powertrain DTC Type Definitions (factory manual)
- RDW, APK handbook: Regulations, articles 42 and 45a to 45g (version from 1 January 2024) (in Dutch)
- RDW, APK Keurmeester no. 110 (September 2025): when is a soot measurement required? (in Dutch)
How we set prices ›
The amounts come from prices that Dutch garages and webshops publish on their own sites, including VAT, or from the source shown next to them. Last collected on 19 November 2026. Your own price depends on your engine and year, so always ask for a quote. The ANWB (the Dutch motoring club) gives an average, which is not a real price, so we leave it out. If your garage asks something very different, email it to hallo@vroomdoctor.com.