---
title: "Catalytic converter or lambda sensor? | Vroom Doctor"
description: "With P0420 it’s often the lambda sensor or an exhaust leak, sometimes the catalytic converter. A sensor costs €112 to €120 at the garage, a catalytic."
canonical: https://vroomdoctor.com/compare/catalytic-converter-or-lambda-sensor
language: en
---


# Catalytic converter or lambda sensor?

With P0420 it’s often the lambda sensor behind the catalytic converter, or a leak in the exhaust. Have the garage compare both sensors first. A sensor costs €112 to €120 fitted, a catalytic converter usually €470.

|  | Lambda sensor | Catalytic converter |
| --- | --- | --- |
| What it does | Measures oxygen in the exhaust gas | Converts harmful exhaust gases |
| Garage, fitted | €112 to €120 | Usually €470 (€329 to €750) |
| Part only | €57 to €100 | €193 to €286 |
| Lasts | No fixed interval, Bosch: have it checked every 30,000 km | At least 10 years or 150,000 km (ANWB) |
| Codes | P0130 to P0167 | P0420, P0430 |

## How the garage tells the difference

There’s a lambda sensor in front of and behind the catalytic converter. The front one swings quickly. A good catalytic converter dampens that swing, so the rear one stays steady.

If the rear sensor swings just as hard as the front one, the catalytic converter is storing too little oxygen. If the rear sensor reacts slowly or not at all, the sensor itself is the suspect.

## The cheap causes first

A leak in the exhaust in front of the sensor gives a false reading. With a cold engine, listen for ticking or blowing at the manifold and the flex pipe.

Is there also a code for misfires or mixture, such as P0300 or P0171? Fix that first. The catalytic converter test only runs once those codes are gone.

## Why a new catalytic converter breaks again

According to the ANWB, a catalytic converter often fails early because of incomplete combustion, such as worn spark plugs. If that cause stays, the new one breaks too.

So ask the garage why the old one failed before you have a new one fitted.

## What to ask the garage

Which other codes are there, and can I have the printout?

Did you measure both lambda sensors, or only read the code?

Has the exhaust been checked for leaks?

What does an original part cost, and what does an aftermarket one cost?

Why did the old catalytic converter fail?

## Sources

- [ANWB, The catalytic converter (Dutch)](https://www.anwb.nl/auto/onderhoud-en-reparatie/auto-onderdelen/katalysator)

- [Saab WIS, 9-4X 2011 V6: DTC P0420 or P0430 (factory manual)](https://saabwisonline.com/9-4x/2011/2-engine/engine-management-and-fuel-system-v6/fault-diagnosis-diagnostic-trouble-codes/dtc-p0420-or-p0430-lf1-lfw)

- [Bosch, Lambda sensor brochure (EN)](https://www.boschaftermarket.com/xrm/media/images/country_specific/ea/parts_17/gasoline_parts_3/pdf_19/pag_lamba_sensor_enduser_mini_brochure_en.pdf)

- [Vroom Doctor price data: published garage prices, 19 November 2026](https://vroomdoctor.com/data/prices.json)

- [RDW APK handbook, Noise and environment (passenger cars) (Dutch)](https://apk-handboek.rdw.nl/personenautos/motor/geluid-en-milieu)

## Background

How the lambda sensors measure

How it works ›

### How the engine computer tests the catalytic converter

The catalytic converter stores oxygen. On the Saab 9-4X V6, the computer briefly makes the mixture richer and then leaner at idle. If the rear sensor reacts almost as fast as the front one, it sets P0420.

That test only runs if there are no codes for misfires, mixture or lambda sensors.

### In numbers

**Replacing a lambda sensor, garage:**

€112 to €1204

**Replacing a catalytic converter, garage:**

usually €470 (€329 to €750)4

**New catalytic converter (ANWB):**

€500 to €1,0001

**Catalytic converter lifespan:**

At least 10 years or 150,000 km1

**Checking the lambda sensor:**

Every 30,000 km (Bosch advice)3

**Lambda value at the APK (the Dutch MOT), petrol:**

Between 0.97 and 1.035

## Questions

### Can I keep driving with P0420?

Usually yes, gently. If the engine light flashes, the engine is misfiring. Stop then, because the catalytic converter can overheat.

### Is an aftermarket catalytic converter good enough?

It has to fit and pass the APK emissions test. Ask the garage for both prices.

### Will the APK fail on P0420?

Not on the code alone. With a P code the inspector measures the exhaust gases. If those are too high, you fail.

## See also

- [Best OBD2 scanner in 2026: prices and subscriptions compared](https://vroomdoctor.com/compare/best-obd2-scanner-in-2026)

- [A FIXD alternative for the Netherlands](https://vroomdoctor.com/compare/a-fixd-alternative-for-the-netherlands)

- [Carly vs OBDeleven: the difference in price and features](https://vroomdoctor.com/compare/carly-vs-obdeleven)

- [ELM327 scanner: what is it and does it work?](https://vroomdoctor.com/compare/elm327-scanner)

- [Read your car yourself or at the garage?](https://vroomdoctor.com/compare/read-your-car-yourself)

Was this helpful?

19 November 2026 · 5 sources · [In het Nederlands](https://vroomdoctor.com/nl/vergelijk/katalysator-of-lambdasonde)

## Sources

All sources checked on 19 November 2026.

- [ANWB, The catalytic converter (Dutch)](https://www.anwb.nl/auto/onderhoud-en-reparatie/auto-onderdelen/katalysator)

- [Saab WIS, 9-4X 2011 V6: DTC P0420 or P0430 (factory manual)](https://saabwisonline.com/9-4x/2011/2-engine/engine-management-and-fuel-system-v6/fault-diagnosis-diagnostic-trouble-codes/dtc-p0420-or-p0430-lf1-lfw)

- [Bosch, Lambda sensor brochure (EN)](https://www.boschaftermarket.com/xrm/media/images/country_specific/ea/parts_17/gasoline_parts_3/pdf_19/pag_lamba_sensor_enduser_mini_brochure_en.pdf)

- [Vroom Doctor price data: published garage prices, 19 November 2026](https://vroomdoctor.com/data/prices.json)

- [RDW APK handbook, Noise and environment (passenger cars) (Dutch)](https://apk-handboek.rdw.nl/personenautos/motor/geluid-en-milieu)

## One payment, no subscription.

Vroom Doctor is a small device that sits under your steering wheel. The app is free.

[Pre-order for €59](https://vroomdoctor.com/order)
