Skip to content

P0172: Mixture too rich (bank 1)

Your engine is getting too much petrol for the air, on bank 1. Usually it is a dirty mass airflow sensor (MAF), sometimes a leaking injector.

Within a monthYou can keep driving. Have it checked within a month, that spares your catalytic converter.

How bad
Within a month
Do it yourself
Possible, if you are handy
Garage
€112 to €600

What you notice

  • You use more petrol
  • The exhaust smells strongly of petrol
  • Black soot in the tailpipe
  • Rough idle
  • Sometimes a misfire when the engine is cold

What usually causes it

CauseLikelihood
Dirty mass airflow sensor, measures too little airCommon
Leaking or sticking injector on bank 1Sometimes
Lambda sensor before the catalytic converter (bank 1) wrongly reports lean · €116Sometimes
Dirty air filterSometimes
Temperature sensor reports a cold engineSometimes
Charcoal canister valve (EVAP) stays openSometimes
Faulty pressure regulator, fuel pressure too highRare

A code points to the area. Sometimes the garage only finds the real cause after that.

How to fix it

Start with what costs least.

  1. 1If the air filter is dirty, replace it.
  2. 2If P0175 is there too, both banks are too rich. Then look at what they share: the mass airflow sensor or the fuel pressure.
  3. 3Look at the live data in the app. When warm, the coolant should be around 90 °C. With a rich mixture, the long-term trim drops well below 0%.
  4. 4Clean the mass airflow sensor with MAF cleaner. Do not touch the sensing element.
  5. 5Have the charcoal canister valve checked. At idle it should be closed.
  6. 6Have the fuel pressure measured. Also have the injectors tested for leaks.
  7. 7If the lambda sensor before the catalytic converter (bank 1) reacts slowly or is stuck, fit a new one.

What to ask the garage

  • Which other codes are stored, and can I have the printout?
  • Which measurement shows that this is the cause?
  • What will it cost if you find more? Call me before you go ahead.

If you wait

The manual names a rich mixture as one of the causes of a worn catalytic converter. According to the ANWB (the Dutch motoring club), a new catalytic converter costs 500 to 1,000 euros.

  1. First drive with the fault

    The computer stores the fault.

  2. Second drive in a row

    The engine warning light comes on.

  3. Weeks of driving on

    A rich mixture puts strain on the catalytic converter.

  4. At the APK (the Dutch MOT)

    The APK inspector measures the exhaust gases. If they are too high, you fail the APK.

What it costs

It depends on the cause. Where do the prices come from? ›

PartAt the garagePart only
Mass airflow sensorGarage nonePart €72
InjectorsGarage nonePart €117
Lambda sensorGarage €116Part €79
Catalytic converterGarage €339Part €240

Background

Air filterMass airflow sensorThrottleInjectorIntake manifoldTo exhaustPistonFuel tankFuel pump
How the air and fuel mixture is made
How it works ›

What fuel trim is

The engine computer controls the mixture based on the signal from the lambda sensor. Each adjustment is called fuel trim. The short-term trim reacts quickly. The long-term trim follows slowly and absorbs lasting deviations.

Ideal is 0 per cent. A negative value means the computer takes fuel away because the mixture is too rich. P0172 is about bank 1, the side of cylinder 1.

When the computer sets the code

On the Saab 9-4X V6, the computer looks at the weighted average of the long-term trim. If that stays outside the limit for about 3 minutes, the code follows. Normally the trim is between -10 and +10 per cent.

According to the manual, do not replace a lambda sensor as long as there is no separate sensor code with it. A mass airflow sensor can measure wrongly without its own code.

In numbers

Normal fuel trim
Between -10 and +10 %, ideal 0 %1
Code set after
About 3 minutes of abnormal long-term trim1
Front lambda sensor signal
About 40 to 900 mV, switching with the mixture1
Too rich at idle (Saab 9-4X V6)
Total trim below -40 % gives P21882
New catalytic converter (ANWB)
€500 to €1,0004
Engine warning light on
On the second drive in a row with the same fault5

Questions

What does bank 1 mean with P0172?

The side of the engine with cylinder 1. A normal inline four-cylinder engine only has bank 1.

Can I keep driving with P0172?

Yes, gently. Have it checked within a month, because a mixture that is too rich fouls your spark plugs and catalytic converter.

Will I pass the APK (the Dutch MOT) with P0172?

Not on the code alone. With a P-code in the memory, the APK inspector measures the exhaust gases. You only fail the APK if that measurement is too high. The rules for each fuel type are in the APK guide. A mixture that is too rich can give values that are too high in that measurement.

Can a mixture that is too rich damage the catalytic converter?

Yes, over time. Unburnt petrol makes the catalytic converter too hot and fouls it. A new one costs much more than fixing the cause.

See also

Show 4 more ›

Was this helpful?

· 6 sources · In het Nederlands

Sources

All sources checked on 19 November 2026.

  1. Saab WIS, 9-4X 2011 V6: DTC P0171, P0172, P0174 or P0175 (factory manual)
  2. Saab WIS, 9-4X 2011 V6: DTC P2178 or P2188 (factory manual)
  3. Saab WIS, 9-4X 2011 V6: DTC P0420 or P0430 (factory manual)
  4. ANWB, What is a catalytic converter and when does it need replacing? (in Dutch)
  5. Saab WIS, 9-4X 2011: Powertrain DTC Type Definitions (factory manual)
  6. RDW, APK handbook Regulations, articles 42 and 45a to 45g (version from 1 January 2024) (in Dutch)
How we set prices ›

The amounts come from prices that Dutch garages and webshops publish on their own sites, including VAT, or from the source shown next to them. Last collected on 19 November 2026. Your own price depends on your engine and year, so always ask for a quote. The ANWB (the Dutch motoring club) gives an average, which is not a real price, so we leave it out. If your garage asks something very different, email it to hallo@vroomdoctor.com.