- How bad
- Within a month
- Do it yourself
- Possible, if you are handy
- Usually
- Warm-up catalytic converter worn
- Garage
- usually €339
What you notice
- The engine warning light is on
- Usually you notice nothing while driving
- Sometimes a sulphur smell after a cold start
What usually causes it
| Cause | Likelihood |
|---|---|
| Warm-up catalytic converter worn · €339 | Common |
| Lambda sensor behind the catalytic converter reads incorrectly · €116 | Common |
| Exhaust leak at the manifold | Sometimes |
| Engine misfires or runs too rich · €115 | Sometimes |
| Thermostat stuck open (engine warms up slowly) | Rare |
A code points to the area. Sometimes the garage only finds the real cause after that.
How to fix it
Start with what costs least.
- 1Are there also codes for misfire or mixture? Fix those first.
- 2On a cold start, listen at the exhaust manifold for ticking.
- 3Have the lambda sensors compared during warm-up.
- 4Does the rear sensor not respond properly? Replace it.
- 5Replace the warm-up catalytic converter. On many cars it is attached to the exhaust manifold.
What to ask the garage
- Which other codes are stored, and can I have the printout?
- Which measurement shows that this is the cause?
- What does an original part cost, and what does a pattern part cost?
- What will it cost if you find more? Call me before you go ahead.
If you wait
According to the ANWB (the Dutch motoring club), a catalytic converter lasts at least 10 years or 150,000 km with normal use. The manual names misfires, oil or coolant consumption, a weak spark and a mixture that is too lean or too rich as causes of early wear. If such a cause remains, a new catalytic converter will wear out too.
First drive with the fault
On the Saab 9-4X V6, the engine warning light comes on straight away.
Weeks of driving on
The car drives normally. More CO, hydrocarbons and NOx pass through the catalytic converter.
At the APK
With a P code stored, the APK inspector measures the exhaust gases. If they are too high, you fail the APK.
What it costs
It depends on the cause. Where do the prices come from? ›
| Part | At the garage | Part only |
|---|---|---|
| Catalytic converter | Garage €339 | Part €240 |
| Lambda sensor | Garage €116 | Part €79 |
| Spark plugs | Garage €115 | Part €7 |
| Thermostat | Garage none | Part €20 |
Background
How it works ›
How the engine computer tests the catalytic converter
The catalytic converter turns hydrocarbons, CO and NOx into water vapour, CO2 and nitrogen. It also stores oxygen. Behind the catalytic converter sits a second lambda sensor. With it, the engine computer measures how much oxygen the converter can still store.
P0421 is about the warm-up catalytic converter on bank 1, the one closest to the engine. The test looks at the phase in which it warms up. If the sensors before and after the catalytic converter give almost the same value, the converter stores too little oxygen, according to HELLA.
When the computer sets the code
On the Saab 9-4X V6, the test runs at idle with a warm catalytic converter. The computer briefly makes the mixture richer and then leaner again. A good catalytic converter damps that swing. If the rear sensor reacts almost as fast as the front one, the computer sets the code.
The Saab 9-4X V6 has no separate code for the warm-up phase and reports a weak catalytic converter as P0420. The test only runs if no codes are stored for misfire, mixture or lambda sensors.
In numbers
- Test runs at (Saab 9-4X V6)
- Idle, coolant 40 to 127 °C, catalytic converter 450 to 850 °C1
- Tests per drive (Saab 9-4X V6)
- 1 per idle period, up to 81
- Engine warning light on (Saab 9-4X V6)
- Straight away, on the first failed test4
- Catalytic converter lifespan
- At least 10 years or 150,000 km3
- New catalytic converter (ANWB)
- €500 to €1,000, depending on the car3
- Engine warning light goes off
- After 3 drives in a row without the fault5
Questions
What is a warm-up catalytic converter?
A small catalytic converter close to the engine. It warms up quickly. That way it already cleans the exhaust gases shortly after a cold start.
Will my car fail the APK (the Dutch MOT) on P0421?
Usually not on the light alone. The APK inspector does measure the exhaust gases. A poor catalytic converter can make the car fail on that test.
Is P0421 worse than P0420?
No. It is the same kind of problem as P0420. Only the moment of testing differs.
See also
- P0420: Catalytic converter efficiency too low (bank 1)
- P0430: Catalytic converter efficiency too low (bank 2)
- P0136: Lambda sensor circuit fault (bank 1, sensor 2)
- P0141: Lambda sensor heater circuit fault (bank 1, sensor 2)
- P0128: Coolant below thermostat regulating temperature
- Catalytic converter
- Lambda sensor
- Engine warning light
Was this helpful?
· 6 sources · In het Nederlands
Sources
All sources checked on 19 November 2026.
- Saab WIS, 9-4X 2011 V6: DTC P0420 or P0430 (factory manual)
- HELLA Tech World, Exhaust gas aftertreatment: design and diagnostics
- ANWB, What is a catalytic converter and when does it need replacing? (in Dutch)
- Saab WIS, 9-4X 2011: Powertrain DTC Type Definitions (factory manual)
- UNECE Regulation No. 83, Annex 11 (OBD), paragraphs 3.3 to 3.8
- RDW, APK handbook Regulations, article 42 and 45a to 45g (version from 1 January 2024) (in Dutch)
How we set prices ›
The amounts come from prices that Dutch garages and webshops publish on their own sites, including VAT, or from the source shown next to them. Last collected on 19 November 2026. Your own price depends on your engine and year, so always ask for a quote. The ANWB (the Dutch motoring club) gives an average, which is not a real price, so we leave it out. If your garage asks something very different, email it to hallo@vroomdoctor.com.