- How bad
- Within a month
- Do it yourself
- No, that is a garage jobYou can change the oil in a manual gearbox yourself. You do need to get the car safely up in the air and reach the fill and drain plugs. The rest is work for a garage or a transmission specialist. Got an automatic? Have the fault codes read first. Sometimes it’s a sensor or the software.
Prices
Including 21% VAT, 19 November 2026. Where do they come from? ›
Garage, with labour
Middle of 2, €1,800 to €2,500.
- Vaartland tabel gemiddelde kosten19 Nov€1,800
- Carpardoo magazine19 Nov€2,500
ANWB: average €2,500. Not counted.
What it does
It turns your engine’s revs into the speed of your wheels. You shift a manual yourself with the clutch. An automatic or DSG shifts on its own. Inside, gears, bearings and synchro rings turn in oil.
How you notice
- Changing gear feels stiff, or it grinds
- It jumps out of gear
- A singing or whining noise that rises with your speed
- An automatic that jerks or slips when it shifts
- An oil stain under the middle of your car
- A gearbox warning light, or an automatic in limp mode
When to replace it
A manual gearbox usually has no fixed oil change. According to the ANWB (the Dutch motoring club), the oil should in theory last the life of the car. ZF Aftermarket recommends an oil change for automatics every 150,000 km, depending on how you drive. With a DSG it depends on the type: every 60,000 km for the 6-speed DQ250 and every 120,000 km for the 7-speed DQ381. Check your service book.
If you wait
Changing gear gets stiffer
The synchromesh rings are worn. It grinds when you select a gear.
Gearbox jumps out of gear
A bearing, gear or selector fork may be worn or broken.
DSG jerks when pulling away
Dirty oil gets in the way of the mechatronics. The gearbox shifts later.
Limp mode
The mechatronics unit fails. Then you often can’t avoid an expensive repair.
Background
How it works ›
How a gearbox works
The gears in a manual gearbox turn freely on their shaft. When you change gear, a selector sleeve locks the chosen gear to the shaft. Synchromesh rings first even out the speed difference between gear and shaft. The oil lubricates and cools the gearbox. It also carries dirt away.
A regular automatic has a torque converter instead of a clutch pedal. A dual-clutch automatic, like Volkswagen’s DSG, has two half-gearboxes: one for the even gears and one for the odd gears. A CVT has no fixed gears.
What wears a gearbox out
The synchromesh rings take the most strain. When they’re worn, changing gear gets harder and you hear grinding. If the gearbox jumps out of gear, bearings, gears or a broken selector fork can also be the cause.
With a DSG the oil matters more. Old oil holds deposits and dirt that can clog the valves of the mechatronics unit. At high operating temperatures, the oil in an automatic ages faster.
If you keep driving on it
A DSG with dirty oil starts to jerk when you pull away. It also shifts later. After that, the mechatronics unit can suddenly fail. Once the gearbox goes into limp mode, you often can’t avoid an expensive repair.
In an overhaul, a manual gearbox usually gets new synchromesh rings and new bearings if needed. If the oil from an automatic smells burnt or has metal particles in it, have a specialist check the gearbox.
In numbers
- Wears fastest in a manual gearbox
- Synchromesh rings1
- Manual gearbox oil
- In theory lasts the life of the car1
- Automatic oil change according to ZF Aftermarket
- Every 150,000 km, depending on how you drive2
- DSG DQ250 oil change (6-speed)
- Every 60,000 km3
- DSG DQ381 oil change (7-speed)
- Every 120,000 km3
- Overhaul according to the ANWB
- About €2,500 including fitting1
Questions
What does a gearbox overhaul cost?
Between €1,800 and €2,500 at garages that list their prices online, also for a replacement gearbox. The ANWB puts it at around €2,500 including fitting. A used gearbox with a warranty is sometimes cheaper.
Is an overhaul or a used gearbox better?
An overhauled gearbox has new bearings and rings, and usually a warranty. A used one is cheaper. You just don’t know how it’s been treated. Ask about the warranty period for both.
Can I keep driving with a grinding gear?
If it only grinds when you select the gear, you can usually keep going for a while. Does the gearbox jump out of gear, or do you hear a loud noise? Then have it checked soon.
Is it always the gearbox when changing gear is hard?
No. With a manual it’s often a worn clutch or a leaking clutch cylinder. That’s cheaper than a gearbox.
See also
Was this helpful?
· 3 sources · In het Nederlands
Sources
All sources checked on 19 November 2026.